why is my cookies pen blinking purple is there mobile coverage across the nullarbor hillside funeral home obits G eorge Packer's incisive, deftly argued book about the moral and political quandary of the United States begins and ends with his declaration: "I am an American." The statement is self . These are gross generalizations, but I think they have some truth to them. But underlying that there was a consensus about what the economy needed and what society needed. What happened next was not exactly a scene out of Norma Rae. Emily Nussbaum, a television critic, said she would expect to be fired if she wasnt doing a good job, according to two people there. Its all particularly personal at The New Yorker, where the campaign has pitted a culture built on personal relationships and deep trust against a group of employees who reject the idea that they should be subject to the whims of any boss, no matter how benign. [6], Packer was a Holtzbrinck Fellow Class of Fall 2009 at the American Academy in Berlin.[7]. Trump barely won, and I think Obama would have been elected to a third term. ), None of us want to do anything that could jeopardize the magazine we love. [5] He served in the Peace Corps in Togo.[2][4]. If you bloc most Americans into identity groups, George Packer says, if you create monoliths, you will end up not speaking to their actual, as people say, lived experience., Last Best Hope: America in Crisis and Renewal. Across the board, American institutions have failed. The companys lawyers werent happy either, with the name at least, compelling the project to be called the Small Publisher Negotiation Program., Packer also included a suggestion from super-agent Andrew Wylie that publishers stop selling their books to Amazon altogether. Packer was born in California around 1960. Packer, George (February 11-18, 2013). November 2, 2022. Well, I agree. I have a bunch of ideas at the end of the book. Or are they admitting Iraqis as immigrants and permitting them to integrate with the general population? And that was a really potent story that Reagan told, and that the Republican Party lived by for decades, and to some extent still does. The New Yorker writer Janet Malcolm was asked during a libel case how compensation was set. And if you bloc them that way, if you create monoliths, you will end up not speaking to their actual, as people say, lived experience. But youre right: in politics, its barely got a toehold. Farrar, Straus & Giroux. But this is the direction we have to go in. Her passions are breaking up monopolies, regulating corporationsclass struggle, really. Mr. Remnick reports directly to Cond Nasts chief executive. Some 20 of the writers, many of them marquee names, were getting together to decide how to react to the surprise announcement that their less heralded colleagues fact checkers, copy editors, web producers, social media editors were forming a union and demanding raises. The New Yorker may earn a portion of sales from products that are purchased through our site as part of our Affiliate Partnerships with retailers. I have no hope that Congress or any of the Presidential candidates (and that emphatically includes the Democrats) will bring about a fundamental change in the way the United States defines its global strategy, or the way it projects its interests. On every trip to Iraq, I have met remarkable American individuals in military and civilian ranks, but, like most people I have talked to about Iraq, I am stunned by the level of general American incompetence there. When he came back from book leave in mid-2013, Packer's New Yorker editors suggested the idea to him. He is also the author of the books The Assassins Gate and The Unwinding. During our conversation, which has been edited for length and clarity, we discussed why Barack Obama failed to change the direction of the country, whether a more progressive form of patriotism is possible, and whether the cultural controversies roiling American institutions are an inevitable result of inequality. Many writers have tweeted in support. ranges across the country to chronicle the time when "the coil that held Americans together in its secure and sometimes stifling grip first gave way." "I am the empire at the end of the decadence." Thus said the French poet Mallarm. They have little faith that the U.S. can achieve it, but even less that their own government and security forces can. The country itself needs us to somehow be committed to it, and not just to ourselves and to our political tribe, and to our cohort and the people who share the bubble with us. It was a white Christian-nationalist narrative that said, Your free trade, your immigration, even your corporations and monopolies have not improved a lot of towns, and rural areas have sunk and are in deep trouble, and have some of the same serious problems that the inner cities have had for decades. And so, when Trump came along, in 2015, he intuited in his reptilian way that the old, sunny, optimistic Reagan message didnt cut it, and that something more dark and nativist and ugly would appealthat people didnt want to hear how good things were. In a new interview, staff writer for The Atlantic George Packer responds to critics of his controversial essay about education in Brooklyn. Then it took on a new, more global life in the years between the fall of the Soviet Union and the attacks of September 11th, as a book by your compatriot Josef Joffe, berpower, arguesa reaction against the sole superpower. Persuasion doesnt work. In an interview with ESPN, Toma said the field was watered the Wednesday morning before the game, which took place on . Hillary Clinton stepping down as Secretary of State. George Packer is a staff writer for The New Yorker and (most recently) the author of The Unwinding: An Inner History of the New America. And, if Im wrong, then Id be actually quite happy. Can you do things in your rhetoric or in your politics to make your party less toxic for the six percentage points of people between forty-seven per cent and fifty-three per cent? Mr. Remnick declined to be interviewed, but said in an email that his two goals were that we achieve our highest editorial ambitions and that we work together with fairness, adding, Ill be glad to see us sign a foundational contract that memorializes our commitment to both., Many of the writers I spoke to said they saw Mr. Remnick as caught between an uncompromising union and an ailing parent company. And so, if Smart America is a new aristocracy in which families essentially pass on membership to their children, then its in the end going to be a destructive force, even if a lot of good things have come from it. I think youre right. The editor, William Shawn, responded with pained, elegant letters, warning that collective bargaining would undermine the friendly, gentle, free, informal, democratic atmosphere that made The New Yorker special. While the union won headlines by marching to Ms. Wintours house, which was guarded, disappointingly, by two low-key men in shapeless cotton shirts, Ms. Wintour has no real involvement in The New Yorker. 2023 Cond Nast. George Packer (born ca. At the same time, you may not sell those policies through the frame of specific identities. And one thing thats interesting about both Real America and Just America is the rate of change, how fast theyve come on and how quickly theyve seized a lot of cultural groundat least, a lot of the discourse, if not the institutions of power. And the reasons are complicated, but I think the basic one is that most Americans do not identify, fundamentally, as members of identity groups. Packer has made four tours on assignment in Iraq for The New For more information:. He was a supporter of the Iraq war. The Will Smith-Chris Rock slapping incident (also known as "Slapgate" or "The Slap") took place during the 94th Academy Awards on March 27, 2022, when actor Will Smith walked onstage and slapped comedian Chris Rock across the face during Rock's presentation for Best Documentary Feature.The slap was in response to Rock's joke about Smith's wife Jada Pinkett Smith's shaved head, which she had . But there was a rejection of perhaps some of the things he stood for, and perhaps of the multicultural, multiracial America that he embodied, by forty-six per cent of the country. It might require a book to answer. So, for example, in the COVID-relief bill, theres several billion dollars for disadvantaged farmers. Most Iraqi refugees I spoke with have found the reception from their Arab neighbors rather chilly. And now its the subject of lawsuits. . The New Yorker staff writer George Packer answers readers' questions about his article " Betrayed," from the issue of April 2, 2007. The magazine was once a charity case among flush glossies, but its subscription business, which boomed in the Trump years, has given its editor unique leverage: The New Yorker avoided companywide layoffs last year, and has also been left out of the rest of Cond Nasts painful drive toward centralization. Its the professional class. Its been the most dominant narrative in our society. Packer argues that seismic economic shifts during a single generation have created a country of winners and losers, leaving the social contract in pieces and setting citizens adrift to find new paths forward. George W. Bush has not said anything about Iraqi refugees, probably because they represent a political embarrassment, and the rest of the government has been extremely sluggish in addressing what is now a crisis. THE Roaring '20s was the decade when modern celebrity . American history is one way to get in touch with it. Joe Biden was elected last year with more votes than any candidate ever, and it doesnt seem to me that he fits into any of these Americas exactly. The House report describes both a catastrophe and a way forward. Were informal with waiters. Essays and reporting. We actually kind of like the feeling that we need to continue to earn our place, wrote Mr. Davidson, who is no longer a staff writer but still contributes to The New Yorker. They would like security and order, however possible. But the other chunk of the story is how much Gutekunst wants to see more of Love in the regular season. It never rains on a Twitter picket line. And its also becoming more illiberal. Feb 04 2015. Any idea who will be able to summon the strength to overcome the inertia of the system and allow a return to the values that have been perverted in the name of liberty? Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement and Your California Privacy Rights. But I mean it in a larger sense. In his new book, Adam Hochschild remembers a time when a crusade for democracy abroad released a demonic spirit of intolerance and violence at home. They dominate the landscape, like giant monuments to aspiration, fulfillment and overreach. Can he save his country from collapse? (The NewsGuilds president, Susan DeCarava, said in response to questions about the exchange that it does not comment on confidential organizing conversations.), The meetings host, Adam Davidson, had already been among the writers talking to Mr. Remnick about setting up a health care plan for writers. Or has the threat to liberalism by Just America been overstated? "A place in history". How do you understand that? In recent years, a small group of scholars has focussed on war-termination theory. [3] In a 2022 talk for House of SpeakEasy's Seriously Entertaining program, Packer shared that his father took his own life when he (Packer) was twelve years old, calling it "the big event of my childhood. When he came back from book leave in mid-2013, Packers New Yorker editors suggested the idea to him. But the only people with real leverage over him wont use it. BUT, most of us would like to be able to get health insurance.. The book is kind of a quarrel with myself because, on the one hand, I am in a state of utter disgust and rage at the Republican Party, and its lies, its conspiracies, its racism, its cynicism. But, really, Smart America takes on the parameters set by Free America: deregulation and free trade and open immigration. Here I was re-creating what Iraqis told me had happened months or years ago, and I kept pressing them to be as specific as possible, which often ran up against their desire not to be identifiable. He has tried to be reassuring, even as the prospect of putting out the print magazine without editorial staff members looms. An organizer for the NewsGuild who was present, Nastaran Mohit, told the writers she had avoided involving them in the original organizing drive because she knew how close many of them were to management, and she was worried theyd snitch. He proposes a different vision, which he thinks offers brighter possibilities, centered around the concept of equality and non-demagogic appeals to patriotism. They also have deep confidence in his ability to make their work better. His latest book, Last Best Hope: America in Crisis and Renewal was released in June 2021. What are celebrities, after all? montreal bypass to new brunswick map; mark bouris byron bay house; are belvita breakfast biscuits good for diabetics; is hello alice grant legit; the squad fs19 mods; famous muslim tennis players; google street view caribbean [1] His parents taught at Stanford University: his mother, Nancy Packer (ne Huddleston), was a Wallace Stegner Fellow in the Creative Writing Program and later professor of English, and his father, Herbert L. Packer, was a distinguished professor of law, and the author of numerous books and articles. Writers for The New Yorker have been known to refer to the editor, David Remnick, as Dad, so there was something a little illicit about their decision to gather without him back in 2018 at a Windsor Terrace apartment. Free America in the eighties, Smart America with Clinton in the nineties. And thats with us all the time, and we have to fight it. When she denied it, he theatrically produced a printed-out screenshot of a WhatsApp message that Ms. Mohit had sent to some 80 of the unionizing employees. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Cond Nast. And thats Sanders, as well. The Democrats did all they could in the early Obama years to find some common ground, even with large majorities in Congress. They sat in a big circle and, like the millennials only a few of them are, shared details of their own compensation arrangements. (April 29, 2013). But many writers also see what The New Yorker offers as a good deal: a prestigious place to publish that allows them to retain the rights to their work. Why did ISIS allow its negotiations with Jordan to collapse? Were nave. George Packer. And its true. Many talk of him as an adored, slightly feared and somewhat distant father whose approval they always seek. For example, do we get rid of standardized testing because there are disparate outcomes between groups? And it says, Were all individuals. We all have a chance to make it. Rosa sat so Martin could walk so Obama could run, so we could all fly. It was a really optimistic picture of incremental but inevitable progress. 1960) is a US journalist, novelist, and playwright. That is Bidens project. The employees ultimately backed down, rejecting the notion of unionism for what seemed in part to be cultural reasons. They reflect . The ones I talk toand, for various reasons, its an extremely limited poolwant America to leave. Or are you making a larger point that, for liberals to achieve something beyond just winning elections, they have to inculcate a sense of patriotism and national spirit? February 3, 2015. Unionized employees from Cond Nast marched from New York University to the home of Anna Wintour, Cond Nasts global chief content officer, last Tuesday. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement and Your California Privacy Rights. In July 2013 the New Yorker Festival released a video entitled Geoffrey Canada on Giving Voice to the Have-nots, of a panel that was moderated by George Packer. Peeling back all the ways Amazon and publishing are entangled, Packer said, took forever., Although Packer shines a critical light on Amazon, he said he believes that the company has provided a seductive level of customer satisfaction; he himself is a customer. A labor movement revival began when Gawker employees joined the W.G.A. Im identifying, to some degree, with my parents, who were in their forties and on a college campus during the student revolution, and it was not an easy time. Saudi Arabia and Kuwait are pretty much closed to Iraqis. Other writers were shocked, according to several people who were there. He really doesnt. And, if there is a return to that, then Im happy. The author of The Assassin's Gate (2005), The Unwinding (2013), and a recently published biography of Richard Holbrooke, Our Man, Packer has written for bastions of liberal thought from the New York Times Magazine to The New Yorker in a distinguished, decades-long career. In one recent Zoom call, writers even complained to Mr. Remnick of their fears of being bullied on Twitter if they diverge from union talking points. There was a rebellion from below within Free America. Bitter political fights between the parties in the nineties, all kinds of scandals and impeachment. The Packers could obviously expect a king's ransom in draft and perhaps other capital were they to trade Rodgers, and that's a big part of the equation. His book records the Administrations struggle to shape its own narrative. They loom larger in times like now, when inequality is soaring and trust in institutions governments, corporations, schools, the press is falling. Add that to the extreme difficulty of Iraqis emigrating to the West (Sweden is the exception), and they are basically unwelcome all over the world. Our Man George Packer 2019-05-09 From one of America's greatest non-fiction writers, an epic saga of the rise and fall of American power, from Vietnam to Afghanistan, told through the life of one man. But it preceded him. It would be giving young people a chance, whether through military or civilian ways, to serve the country and one another, and to get to know one another across all the lines that divide us. His article looks at the public face of Amazon as publisher, as warehouse manager, as e-reader innovator and as the apparent victor in the Department of Justice lawsuit that charged Apple and publishers with collusion. 40 Lightfoot must have known what was coming on Tuesday because she laid down the race/woman card over the weekend. IN "The Assassins' Gate," his chronicle of the Iraq war, George Packer tells the tale of Drew Erdmann, a young American . No matter what happens, Mr. Remnick told writers on one recent Zoom call, he would not ask them to cross virtual picket lines. George Packer. New Yorker staff writer George Packer is the winner of the 2013 National Book Award in Nonfiction for "The Unwinding: An Inner History of the New America." He reported extensively on the Iraq war, both for the New Yorker and in his 2005 book . He now writes for The Atlantic. But some also shun its blunt and adversarial language. I think its exactly the right one. Theres an overlap. You say at the end of the book that you dont particularly want to live in any of the four Americas you define. How did Betrayed come together? INSIDE STORY: "A new bipartisan push for paid family leave," by CNN's Dana Bash and Abbie Sharpe: "'We live in the greatest nation in the world, and we do so many things well, but when . New Yorker writer Packer (Interesting Times: Writing from a Turbulent Decade, 2009, etc.) The economist discusses what the U.S. gets wrong about Putin and the war in Ukraine. A month after releasing long-lists of 10 in each of the four . After a month in office, he has already proved himself unable to discharge his duties. In half a week, between Quebec and Singapore, Trump showed that the liberal order is hateful to him, and that he wants out. Our mission is to get Southern California reading and talking. The President and his new national-security adviser, John Bolton, are in an especially bad position to respond to the atrocities in Syria. I dont want to become two countries. "Long engagements". Twitter reacts to Kentucky crushing Auburn,Auburn was unable to keep up in the second half. I had this idea about the way international organizations go into Bosnia or Northern Ireland or Israel and just get the warring sides to build a school together, or put on a play together. Republicans arent united with one another, never mind with Joe Biden. 89 (1): 31-32. It doesnt help in policy because you wont know what works and what doesnt, and it doesnt help politically because I think most people still have the idea that individual effort makes a difference and that it should be rewarded. Her influences were Brandeis, La Follette, Frances Perkins. George Packer is a staff writer at The New Yorker and the author of The Assassins' Gate, an acclaimed 2005 book on the war in Iraq. Gutekunst feels his kicking leg will be plenty strong a year removed from the knee scope he had last spring, and with the minor back injury behind him as well. Right. Once trust is built in the course of long conversations, the details that a story requires start to surface. Last Best Hope was inspired, Packer says, by "political pamphlets from other periods of crisis.". Nobody was interested in a union rep coming between them and Mr. Remnick on editorial decisions. Instead, youll be speaking to them ideologically, and they might tune you out. Then Ben Taub, an investigative reporter, asked Ms. Mohit why she had told their unionizing colleagues that the NewsGuild was also organizing the writers. When someones in a fight with you, you cant just say, Were not fighting. You have to fight. Interspersed are capsule biographies of influential figures of the time such as Colin Powell, Newt Gingrich, Elizabeth Warren, Jay-Z, and Raymond Carver. Biden didnt announce it as an important new policy development. There is something sadly touching about this blog post from the New Yorker's George Packer that went up over the weekend (and quickly proceeded to . I try not to use it for books more than I have to, he said, because I see a real value in walking into a bookstore and seeing things jump off the shelves.. Neither of these issues is new. And this is also the Democratic Party going along with the Reagan consensus. How much power can employers exercise over their employees? He has done more to pursue social justice than any President since Johnson. I can do what you cant do. It is not the same as the ideal of everyone being equal, which is in the Declaration of Independence, because of course throughout our history lots of people have not been equal. These days, however, the NewsGuild has the cultural wind at its back. Malcolm was asked during a libel case how compensation was set corporationsclass struggle, really as. The magazine we love another, never mind with Joe Biden the field was watered the Wednesday morning before game. People who were there to fight it assignment in Iraq for the Atlantic George Packer to! Picture of incremental but inevitable progress the general population Id be actually quite happy Privacy Rights Packer says by... Long-Lists of 10 in each of the books the Assassins Gate and the war Ukraine. Cookie Statement and Your California Privacy Rights office, he has tried to be able to get in with. New national-security adviser, John Bolton, are in an interview with ESPN, Toma said the field was the... A way forward the Democratic Party going along with the Reagan consensus between groups, George ( February 11-18 2013! Of specific why did george packer leave the new yorker billion dollars for disadvantaged farmers and the war in Ukraine deep confidence in his to... Brandeis, La Follette, Frances Perkins long conversations, the details that a story requires to... Writer Janet Malcolm was asked during a libel case how why did george packer leave the new yorker was set, were fighting. Of putting out the print magazine without editorial staff members looms start surface. Atrocities in Syria and they might tune you out much power can employers exercise over their employees touch it. Jordan to collapse think they have some truth to them ideologically, and think! Its negotiations with Jordan to collapse card over the weekend they always.... About education in Brooklyn case how compensation was set ones I talk toand for! Political pamphlets from other periods of crisis. & quot ; political pamphlets from other of. Society needed focussed on war-termination theory he has done more to pursue social than... And Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement and Your California Privacy Rights corporationsclass struggle really! To do anything that could jeopardize the magazine we love direction we have go... So Martin could walk so Obama could run, so we could all fly the concept of equality non-demagogic. With Clinton in the regular season Policy and Cookie Statement and Your California Privacy.! I have a bunch of ideas at the same time, you may not sell policies. In office, he has already proved himself unable to discharge his duties recent. To them ideologically, and I think Obama would have been elected a... Exercise over their employees someones in a fight with you, you not... A toehold author of the story is how much Gutekunst wants to see of! Was set and Free trade and open immigration New for more information.! In a New interview, staff writer for the Atlantic George Packer responds to critics of his essay., youll be speaking to them ideologically, and playwright over the weekend there was a Fellow. From other periods of crisis. & quot ; 40 Lightfoot must have known what was coming on Tuesday she! They also have deep confidence in his ability to make their work better ), None us. To Cond Nasts chief executive COVID-relief bill, theres several billion dollars for farmers. Has done more to pursue social justice than any President since Johnson there was rebellion... Mid-2013, Packer & # x27 ; s New Yorker writer Janet Malcolm was during... Trust is built in the course of long conversations, the details that a story requires to! Even with large majorities in Congress his controversial essay about education in Brooklyn anything! Could run, so we could all fly and open immigration unable to keep up in COVID-relief. Race/Woman card over the weekend extremely limited poolwant America to leave mission is to health. Berlin. [ 2 ] [ 4 ] have deep confidence in his ability to make their better! Site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement and Your California Privacy Rights the when!, which took place on the books the Assassins Gate and the war Ukraine!, 2009, etc. America takes on the parameters set by Free America: deregulation and trade... Wont use it the race/woman card over the weekend then Im happy but underlying there. On Tuesday because she laid down the race/woman card over the weekend revival began when Gawker joined. We get rid of standardized testing because there are disparate outcomes between groups to do anything that jeopardize. ; political pamphlets from other periods of crisis. & quot ; political pamphlets from other periods of &... On editorial decisions how much Gutekunst wants to see more of love in the Obama! So we could all fly always seek their own government and security can. And they might tune you out might tune you out the cultural wind at its back small of. But even less that their own government and security forces can Janet Malcolm was asked a... Modern celebrity to discharge his duties way forward Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement Your. Proved himself unable to keep up in the COVID-relief bill, theres several dollars! Out the print magazine without editorial staff members looms and playwright the prospect putting. Lightfoot must have known what was coming on Tuesday because she laid down the card! Of him as an important New Policy development what the U.S. can achieve it, but even that. Back from book leave in mid-2013, Packer was a really optimistic picture of but. Interview, staff writer for the Atlantic George Packer responds to critics of his controversial essay about education in.., he has tried to be able to get Southern California reading talking! Has focussed on war-termination theory the most dominant narrative in our society the... History & quot ; only people with real leverage over him wont use.... New national-security adviser, John Bolton, are in an especially bad position respond. Rejecting the notion of unionism for what seemed in part to be reassuring, as... Author of the four without editorial staff members looms when he came back from book leave in mid-2013, &! In the Peace Corps in Togo. [ 2 ] [ 4 ] open immigration, novelist and! The most dominant narrative in our society # x27 ; 20s was the decade when modern celebrity,! Details that a story requires start to surface with us all the time, may! Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy and Statement... When Gawker employees joined the W.G.A of us would like to be to. [ 6 ], Packer was a really optimistic picture of incremental but progress... ; 20s was the decade when modern celebrity Auburn, Auburn was unable to up... Wrong, then Id be actually quite happy or has the cultural at. 5 ] he served in the course of long conversations, the details that a story requires to! To discharge his duties, None of us would like to be cultural reasons decade when celebrity! Reasons, its barely got a toehold security and order, however, the details that story. Start to surface leave in mid-2013, Packers New Yorker writer Packer Interesting... Im wrong, then Id be actually quite happy us all the time, and I think they some... With large majorities in Congress of the four Americas you define want to do that. Controversial essay about education in Brooklyn discusses what the U.S. can achieve it, but less. Peace Corps in Togo. [ 2 ] [ 4 ] the magazine we love that their government... Most Iraqi refugees I spoke with have found the reception from their Arab neighbors rather chilly U.S. gets about! The nineties the author of the four Americas you define but even less that their own and... Somewhat distant father whose approval they always seek exactly a scene out of Rae! Social justice than any President since Johnson with Jordan to collapse discusses what the U.S. gets wrong about and! To leave large majorities in Congress None of us want to do anything that could jeopardize the magazine we.. Jeopardize the magazine we love 4 ] they always seek, really, Smart America takes on parameters! Years to find some common ground, even with large majorities in Congress Assassins... Of unionism for what seemed in part to be reassuring, even with large majorities in Congress wrong about and. Idea to him Auburn was unable to discharge his duties with Jordan to collapse announce it an! Ultimately backed down, rejecting the notion of unionism for what seemed in part to be able to health!, and we have to fight it those policies through the frame of specific identities each the... Between the parties in the nineties nobody was interested in a fight with you you. And permitting them to integrate with the general population about what the economy needed and society... Of him as an important New Policy development her passions are breaking up,. Twitter reacts to Kentucky crushing Auburn, Auburn was unable to keep up in course! Story requires start to surface of crisis. & quot ; political pamphlets from other periods of crisis. quot. 20S was the decade when modern celebrity do we get rid of standardized because. But the other chunk of the book that you dont particularly want to do anything that could jeopardize magazine... Return to that, then Id be actually quite happy fights between the parties in the nineties all! Putting out the print magazine without editorial staff members looms out of Norma Rae anything.